The Archetypal Sunni Scholar: Law, Theology, and Mysticism in the Synthesis of al-Bajuri

The book is a lucid survey and deep analysis of the works and ideas of al-Bājūrī and shows precisely how al-Bājūrī served as an ‘archetypal’ Sunnī scholar.

This is a rare study of a late premodern Islamic thinker, Ibrahim al- Bājūrī, a nineteenth-century scholar and rector of Cairo’s al-Azhar University. The writer, Aaron Spevack, explores al- Bājūrī’s legal, theological, and mystical thought, highlighting its originality and vibrancy in relation to the millennium of scholarship that preceded and informed it, and also detailing its continuing legacy. The book makes a case for the normativity of the Gabrielian Paradigm, the study of law, rational theology, and Sufism, in the person of al- Bājūrī. Soon after his death in 1860, this typical pattern of scholarship would face significant challenges from modernists, reformers, and fundamentalists. Spevack challenges beliefs that rational theology, syllogistic logic, and Sufism were not part of the predominant conception of orthodox scholarship and shows this scholarly archetype has not disappeared as an ideal. In addition, the book contests prevailing beliefs in academic and Muslim circles about intellectual decline from the thirteenth through nineteenth centuries.

“Reading against the Orientalist model of Islamic intellectual tradition, which was preoccupied with the notions of independence, creativity and progress, this book offers an alternative approach to nineteenth-century Islamic scholarship, focusing on the normative or ideal platform that Muslim scholars like al-Bājūrī wished to preserve. The book also serves as a reminder … that the categorical devaluation of postclassical Islamic scholarship produced by early Orientalist scholars and Muslim reformists alike, does not adequately reflect the Islamic legal, theological, and mystical tradition. A more sympathetic reading of nineteenth-century Islamic scholarship, such as Spevack’s, may perhaps open up multiple trajectories of Islamic tradition that will give us a better understanding of the Islamic world today.”

The viewpoint of the others about the book

“Spevack’s trailblazing book is a lucid survey and deep analysis of the works and ideas of al-Bājūrī. Spevack shows precisely how al-Bājūrī served as an ‘archetypal’ Sunnī scholar. In the process, he succeeds in evoking the subtlety, sophistication, and dynamism of the postclassical Islamic traditions of theology, mysticism, and jurisprudence.” — Robert Wisnovsky, McGill University

“Here is a readable and comprehensive introduction to the intellectual production of one of the last giants of the Sunnī legal tradition in the nineteenth century. Sensitive to the scholar’s strong affiliation with a millennium-long tradition, this introduction will be appreciated by seasoned scholars and newcomers alike.” — Ahmad Atif Ahmad, University of California, Santa Barbara

“Spevack’s book is an important corrective to Eurocentric narratives of the nineteenth century that focus solely on Islamic thinkers whose main concern is with European ‘modernity’ and its challenges while breezily ignoring the continuing tradition of madrasah scholarship in the modern period.” — Khaled El-Rouayheb, Harvard University

About the Author

Aaron Spevack is Assistant Professor of Religion at Colgate University. He translated and annotated Ghazali on the Principles of Islamic Spirituality: Selections from The Forty Foundations of Religion—Annotated and Explained.

Table of Contents

Acknowledgments
Introduction

1. Al-Bājūrī’s Life and Scholarship

A Traditional Shaykh al-Azhar in an Era of Attempted Reform
Al-Bājūrī’s Character
Al-Bājūrī’s Works
Al-Bājūrī’s Commentaries and Their Predecessors
Al-Bājūrī’s Literary Sources and the Commentary Tradition

2. Al-Bājūrī’s View of Religion and Method in the Egyptian Milieu

The Archetype and Method
The Gabrielian Paradigm: Al-Bājūrī’s View of the Three Dimensions of Islam
The Ijmā’-Ikhtilāf Spectrum
The Egyptian Milieu

3. Al-Bājūrī in Dialogue with His Archetypal Predecessors

Al-Bājūrī’s Theological Predecessors
Al-Bājūrī’s Predecessors in Law
Al-Bājūrī’s Sufi Predecessors
The Independent Jurist-Theologian-Sufis and Their Affiliations

4. Al-Bājūrī’s Legal, Theological, and Mystical Thought

Al-Bājūrī on Law: Ijtihād and Taqlīd
Al-Bājūrī on Sufism: Its Goals, Methods, and Explanations or Exclamations
Al-Bājūrī on the Rational Sciences

5. Legacy and Conclusion

Al-Bājūrī’s Legacy

Conclusion
Notes
Bibliography
Index

Bibliographic Information

Title: The Archetypal Sunni Scholar: Law, Theology, and Mysticism in the Synthesis of al-Bajuri

Author: Aaron Spevack

Publisher: State University of New York Press

 Language: English

Length: 220 pages

ISBN: 978-1438453705

Pub. Date: July 2, 2015